Apple iPhone Conspiracy theory – was it all just an elaborate plan by Apple?





I’m not one to sit around all day and come up with wild conspiracy theories (though I could tell you a tale about JFK) but here’s something that has been bugging me since yesterday afternoon. What are the odds that the FCC would announce approval of the iPhone just a day after the false story regarding a delay of the iPhone?

iPhone

The whole thing just doesn’t sit right with me. First, the memo was spoofed very well. It fooled the guys over at Engadget, and they’re one of the biggest tech blogs around. So although it is possible that someone with skill just made this up, I’m willing to bet that it did in fact come from someone inside of Apple. But was it planned by the execs, or even the marketing team? Or was it just some overzealous employee wanting to see how much they could stir things up?

I don’t see an employee doing it of their own accord for the fun of it. If caught, they would be at the very least fired, but likely they would also find themselves facing a lawsuit. So I now turn my thoughts to the idea of a premeditated memo. News of the iPhone is still out there, but there hasn’t been a big breaking story that catches everyone’s eye lately. Now if the iPhone were delayed, everyone would cover that story, right? Well they did, and you know what they say, “no press is bad press.”

So onto the second piece of the conspiracy puzzle, the FCC approval that came only a day later. Some might say it was a coincidence, but in my experience, there’s no such thing as a coincidence. Besides, Apple tends to have some sway over at the FCC. After all, they have managed to keep them quiet about many of the details surrounding the iPhone already. How much of a stretch would it be to find out the exact date they would release the approval documents?

So if one were to believe that Apple knew exactly when the FCC would announce the iPhone’s approval, then there is no doubt that Apple would want everyone to be looking in their direction when the documents became public. So they set into motion one of the biggest breaking stories we’ve seen yet: the iPhone has been delayed several months. Apple knows that there are probably an equal amount of people waiting for the phone to fail as there are wanting it to succeed. So with that thought, good news of the iPhone is going to be covered by many outlets, but very bad news will be covered by nearly all major media sources.

So now all Apple has to do is have someone let loose a memo into the wild with falsified information regarding the iPhone’s delay. Then they can sit back and watch the bad press roll in. Of course when questioned about it they will deny everything and state that it was indeed falsified information. Their stock then drops which causes everyone to turn their head. Before you know it, everyone is looking for any shred of evidence that would let them believe that the iPhone is in fact still on schedule.

Then out of nowhere, a light shines from the heavens. The FCC has approved the iPhone! There can’t be anything stopping it from being released now. So, while the public eye is still fixed upon Apple, they come out with some of the best news yet. Now everyone knows it, and they’re excited about it.

So was it all a huge conspiracy? I don’t know, it seems like a bit of a stretch either way. Like I said, the whole thing just doesn’t sit right with me. It wouldn’t surprise me if Steve Jobs planned out the whole thing himself. After all, he was the second gunman on the grassy knoll.

Subscribe via RSS or Email | Read

9 Responses to “Apple iPhone Conspiracy theory – was it all just an elaborate plan by Apple?”

  1. TQuila says:

    Did anyone from Apple purchase more stock after the “false” memo caused the price to momentarily decline?

  2. TQuila says:

    Or were stock options awarded? I say, follow the money.

  3. toby j. says:

    “Before you know it, everyone is looking for any shred of evidence that would let them believe that the iPhone is in fact still on schedule.”

    The story quoting an official Apple spokesperson that said the earlier release was not issued by Apple was enough for me. This was prior to the FCC news, which apparently Apple runs now.

    Oh and Engagdet has never been known to make a mistake. Or Dan Rather. Or any journalist for that matter. You get too caught up in trying to be first and look what happens. Haste makes waste, or so the story goes.

    “Besides, Apple tends to have some sway over at the FCC. After all, they have managed to keep them quiet about many of the details surrounding the iPhone already. ”

    Do you even know what the FCC does or how it operates? It must be nice to have the time to come up with schemes like this.

  4. jay says:

    HIGHLY doubtful – that announcement killed $4B in market cap for APPL during that brief stint; a fraud which the SEC would be all over.

  5. idannyb says:

    Conspiracy theory – was it all just an elaborate plan by Apple?

    I’m not one to sit around all day and come up with wild conspiracy theories (though I could tell you a tale about JFK) but here’s something that has been bugging me since yesterday afternoon. What are the odds that the FCC would announce approval of the iPhone just a day after the false story regarding a delay of the iPhone?

    Pretty good odds actually … given it’s the month of May 2007 and iPhone is due soon.

    The whole thing just doesn’t sit right with me. First, the memo was spoofed very well. It fooled the guys over at Engadget, and they’re one of the biggest tech blogs around. So although it is possible that someone with skill just made this up, I’m willing to bet that it did in fact come from someone inside of Apple.

    Unknown at present. This could have come from within Apple (disgruntled employee), but more likely, this was conceived and executed externally.

    But was it planned by the execs, or even the marketing team? Or was it just some overzealous employee wanting to see how much they could stir things up?

    Virtually (zero) no chance that this was planned by Apple execs or marketing. Not only would the responsible individual(s) be fired … they’d face litigation, and possibly incarceration and they’d likely never again hold a position of responsibility in any organization.

    Who did this? A geeky prankster? An unscrupulous market manipulator looking to make a fast buck? We may never know. While the SEC has not officially commented about any investigatory role they will take in this matter, you can rest assured they are investigating. As the adage goes – “follow the money!” SEC will scrutinize all trading activity. Who made a quick killing in the immediate aftermath of the announcement? If the trading activity was out of the norm for the account, it will stand out.

    I don’t see an employee doing it of their own accord for the fun of it. If caught, they would be at the very least fired, but likely they would also find themselves facing a lawsuit. So I now turn my thoughts to the idea of a premeditated memo. News of the iPhone is still out there, but there hasn’t been a big breaking story that catches everyone’s eye lately. Now if the iPhone were delayed, everyone would cover that story, right? Well they did, and you know what they say, “no press is bad press.”

    That may be true for Paris or Brittney but not for corporate America and certainly not for shareholders who often take the brunt of “news items” intended to spread fear uncertainty and doubt (FUD).

    So onto the second piece of the conspiracy puzzle, the FCC approval that came only a day later. Some might say it was a coincidence, but in my experience, there’s no such thing as a coincidence.

    Again … FCC announcement was imminent and the motive for market manipulators to spread FUD about iPhone (now) was/is also high as we are near to June launch date.

    Besides, Apple tends to have some sway over at the FCC. After all, they have managed to keep them quiet about many of the details surrounding the iPhone already. How much of a stretch would it be to find out the exact date they would release the approval documents?

    So if one were to believe that Apple knew exactly when the FCC would announce the iPhone’s approval, then there is no doubt that Apple would want everyone to be looking in their direction when the documents became public.

    Virtually all tech blogs and news organizations would have reported on the FCC approval. In my opinion, the phony (negative) “iPhone and Leopard delayed again” e-mail FUD did little or nothing to enhance the (positive) impact of the FCC iPhone approval announcement. In my opinion, tying these two events together in a conspiratorial scheme is a major stretch.

    So they set into motion one of the biggest breaking stories we’ve seen yet: the iPhone has been delayed several months. Apple knows that there are probably an equal amount of people waiting for the phone to fail as there are wanting it to succeed. So with that thought, good news of the iPhone is going to be covered by many outlets, but very bad news will be covered by nearly all major media sources.

    The iPhone is already an exceptionally high profile product. Apple does not need any negative sensationalism to get more publicity. Don’t get me wrong; there will soon be plenty of exciting marketing initiatives to promote the iPhone. My point is that it would be ludicrous for anyone associated with Apple (directly or indirectly) to pull a criminal stunt to get publicity for the iPhone. It is also entirely unnecessary

    So now all Apple has to do is have someone let loose a memo into the wild with falsified information regarding the iPhone’s delay. Then they can sit back and watch the bad press roll in. Of course when questioned about it they will deny everything and state that it was indeed falsified information. Their stock then drops which causes everyone to turn their head. Before you know it, everyone is looking for any shred of evidence that would let them believe that the iPhone is in fact still on schedule.

    Then out of nowhere, a light shines from the heavens. The FCC has approved the iPhone! There can’t be anything stopping it from being released now. So, while the public eye is still fixed upon Apple, they come out with some of the best news yet. Now everyone knows it, and they’re excited about it.

    So was it all a huge conspiracy? I don’t know, it seems like a bit of a stretch either way. Like I said, the whole thing just doesn’t sit right with me. It wouldn’t surprise me if Steve Jobs planned out the whole thing himself. After all, he was the second gunman on the grassy knoll.

    I know that this last comment was meant “tongue-in-cheek”, but in the aftermath of recent and unprecedented FUD campaigns (options matter, etc.) launched against Apple and Steve Jobs, few are in the mood.

    Many Apple investors were hit hard by this little “phony memo”matter … AAPL stop losses were taken out and options positions fluctuated wildly. Tens of millions of dollars were lost during this $4 billion market move in AAPL shares.

  6. Cleverboy says:

    Wow. It’s amazing how lazy people are when they spend the time to write out huge lengthy speculative essays, and absolutely no time to actually research anything they’re talking about. –Especially when its clear this is something they really needed to do. Things seem so much more questionable when people question them.

  7. gadgectchic says:

    im sorry but I think you’re full of crap. why would apple want to lose that much money? the iphone doesn’t need anymore publicity, at this point the only thing that could really stimulate more interest in the iphone is a solid release date.

  8. Just to clear the air a little bit, this article was intended to make you stop and think about the recent events that have happened at Apple. The whole thing is a little odd, and I think that it’s strange that the two events happened so close together.

    Most conspiracy theories are pretty far-fetched, and this one is no different. Do I think that Apple would go that far to just pull off a marketing stunt? As I stated in the article, I think it is a bit of a stretch, I respect them far too much as a company to really believe that they would do that to us. Like people have said, the iPhone doesn’t need any help in the marketing department.

    I was hoping my “second gunman on the grassy knoll” comment would be enough to let you know that the article should be taken in a light-hearted manner, but it’s good to see that so many people are ready to back Apple up with guns blazing. It’s people like you that keeps Apple going strong.


Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.